Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker: Effortlessly Satisfy Your Caffeine Cravings

* This post contains affiliate links, and we will be compensated if you buy after clicking on our links.

Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker

Finding the best 5 cup coffee maker in 2023 can be quite the task, especially when it comes to choosing the ideal size. With a 5-cup coffee maker, you can enjoy the benefits of a compact appliance, without compromising on the freshness and taste of your coffee. These machines are specially designed to cater to your need for a delicious cup of java without making too much or too little. In this article, we’ll delve into the world of 5-cup coffee makers, and explore their advantages, top models on the market, and helpful buying tips.

No matter your taste or preference, investing in one of the top rated 5-cup coffee maker will ensure that you enjoy a remarkable coffee drinking experience each morning. So, let’s dive in and uncover all you need to know about these must-have kitchen appliances.

List Of 15 Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker Reviews

Best Overall

Mr. Coffee 2129512

Mr. Coffee 2129512, 5-Cup Mini Brew Switch Coffee Maker

The Mr. Coffee 2129512 is a simple yet functional rated 5 cup coffee maker that offers an on/off indicator light and features a removable filter basket for quick and easy cleaning.

With a 5-cup capacity, this coffee maker is ideal for those who don’t need a large quantity of coffee.

Pros

Easy to use

Removable filter basket

Cons

Limited features

The Mr. Coffee 2129512, 5-Cup Mini Brew Switch Coffee Maker is a compact and simple coffee maker that can brew up to 25 ounces of coffee, enough for two 12-ounce cups.

It has a few features that make it easy to use and clean, such as the power indicator, the grab-a-cup auto pause, the water window, and the lift and clean filter basket.

Here is our detailed analysis of this coffee maker:

  • Power indicator: The coffee maker has an easy switch with a power indicator that lights up to show when the coffee maker is on, or to remind you to shut it off. This is a useful feature that can help you avoid leaving the coffee maker on for too long, which can affect the taste of the coffee and waste energy. It can also prevent accidents and fire hazards caused by overheating. The power indicator is located on the front of the coffee maker, next to the switch, so you can easily see it from any angle.
  • Grab-a-cup auto pause: The coffee maker has a grab-a-cup auto pause feature that lets you stop the brewing cycle to pour a cup of coffee, then continue brewing until complete. This is a convenient feature that can save you time and prevent you from wasting coffee. You don’t have to wait for the entire pot to finish brewing before you can enjoy your first cup. You can also avoid overfilling the carafe or spilling coffee on the counter. The grab-a-cup auto pause feature works by automatically stopping the flow of coffee when you remove the carafe from the hot plate, and resuming it when you place it back.
  • Water window: The coffee maker has an easy-to-view water window that allows you to see the exact water level, preventing overflows. This is a helpful feature that can help you measure the right amount of water for your desired number of cups. You don’t have to guess or use a separate measuring cup. The water window is located on the side of the coffee maker, above the switch, so you can easily check it while filling the water reservoir.
  • Lift and clean filter basket: The coffee maker has a lift and clean filter basket that makes for easy cleanup. This is a practical feature that can help you keep your coffee maker clean and hygienic. You don’t have to deal with messy grounds or paper filters. You can simply lift the filter basket out of the coffee maker and rinse it under running water or in the dishwasher. The filter basket is compatible with Mr. Coffee Water Filtration Disk & Frame (sold separately), which can help remove chlorine from water and improve coffee taste.

The Mr. Coffee 2129512, 5-Cup Mini Brew Switch Coffee Maker is a good choice for people who want a simple and compact coffee maker that can brew enough coffee for two people.

It has some basic features that make it easy to use and clean, such as the power indicator, the grab-a-cup auto pause, the water window, and the lift and clean filter basket.

It does not have any advanced features such as programmability, temperature control, or strength selection, so it may not suit people who want more customization or variety in their coffee.

It also does not have a thermal carafe or a keep-warm function, so it may not keep your coffee hot for long. However, for its price and size, it is a decent coffee maker that can deliver consistent and satisfying results.


Best Budget

Amazon Basics 5 Cup Coffee Maker

Amazon Basics 5 Cup Coffee Maker with Reusable Filter and Stainless Steel

The Amazon Basics 5 Cup Coffee Maker comes with a reusable filter, saving you from constantly buying paper filters.

Its pause-and-serve function is perfect for users who can’t wait for the brewing process to finish.

Pros

Reusable filter

Pause-and-serve function

Cons

Can be difficult in pouring without spills

This 5 cup brewer is a budget-friendly and easy-to-use coffee maker that can brew up to five cups of coffee at a time.

It has a few features that make it convenient and efficient, such as the reusable filter, the water window, the keep-warm function, and the auto-shutoff feature.

Here is our detailed analysis of this coffee maker:

  • Reusable filter: The coffee maker comes with a removable and reusable filter basket that can save you money and reduce waste. You don’t have to buy disposable paper filters or worry about running out of them. You can simply wash the filter basket after each use and reuse it for the next brew. The filter basket is compatible with the Amazon Basics Water Filtration Disk & Frame (sold separately), which can help remove chlorine and other impurities from water and improve the taste of your coffee.
  • Water window: The coffee maker has a clear water window on the side that lets you see how much water you are adding to the reservoir. This can help you measure the right amount of water for your desired number of cups and prevent overflows or underfills. The water window has markings for 2, 3, 4, and 5 cups, so you can easily adjust the water level according to your preference.
  • Keep-warm function: The coffee maker has a stain-resistant warming plate that keeps your coffee warm until you turn it off. This can ensure that every cup you drink is hot and fresh, even if you brew your coffee ahead of time. The warming plate also has a non-stick coating that makes it easy to clean.
  • Auto-shutoff feature: The coffee maker has an auto-shutoff feature that turns off the machine after 30 minutes of inactivity. This can save you energy and prevent overheating or fire hazards. It can also give you peace of mind if you forget to turn off the coffee maker before leaving home or going to bed.

The Amazon Basics 5 Cup Coffee Maker with Reusable Filter is a good option for people who want a simple and affordable coffee maker that can brew enough coffee for one or two people.

It has some basic features that make it convenient and efficient, such as the reusable filter, the water window, the keep-warm function, and the auto-shutoff feature.

It does not have any advanced features such as programmability, strength selection, or pause-and-serve function, so it may not suit people who want more control or variety in their coffee.

It also does not have a thermal carafe or a permanent filter, so it may not keep your coffee hot for long or reduce sediment in your cup.

However, for its price and size, it is a decent coffee maker that can deliver consistent and satisfying results.


Best Compact

Krups Simply Brew Stainless Steel Drip Coffee Maker

Krups Simply Brew Stainless Steel Drip Coffee Maker

The Krups Simply Brew is a compact 5-cup coffee maker with a dishwasher-safe pot for easy cleaning.

With a 650-watt motor and a drip-free design, it’s an excellent choice for those looking to make a quick and mess-free cup of coffee.

Pros

Compact design,

Dishwasher-safe pot, drip-free spout

Drip-free spout

Cons

I found the taste quality inconsistent

This five cup coffee maker is a compact and simple coffee maker that can brew up to five cups of coffee in one touch.

It has a few features that make it convenient and easy to use, such as the top water tank, the pause and serve system, the keep warm function, and the removable filter basket.

Here is our detailed analysis of this coffee maker:

  • Top water tank: The coffee maker has a top water tank that is easy to fill and has a clear water window that shows the water level. This feature can help you avoid overflows or underfills, which can affect the quality of your coffee. You can easily adjust the water level according to your preference, as the water window has markings for 2, 3, 4, and 5 cups.
  • Pause and serve system: The coffee maker has a pause and serve system that allows you to pour a cup of coffee while brewing, without any mess or interruption. This feature can save you time and prevent you from wasting coffee. You don’t have to wait for the entire pot to finish brewing before you can enjoy your first cup. You can also avoid overfilling the carafe or spilling coffee on the counter. The pause and serve system works by automatically stopping the flow of coffee when you remove the carafe from the warming plate, and resuming it when you place it back.
  • Keep warm function: The coffee maker has a keep warm function that automatically keeps your coffee warm after brewing. This feature can ensure that every cup you drink is hot and fresh, even if you brew your coffee ahead of time. The keep warm function also has a nonstick coating that makes it easy to clean.
  • Removable filter basket: The coffee maker has a removable filter basket that makes for easy cleanup. You don’t have to use paper filters or worry about running out of them. You can simply wash the filter basket after each use and reuse it for the next brew. The filter basket is compatible with the Krups Water Filtration Disk & Frame (sold separately), which can help remove chlorine and other impurities from water and improve the taste of your coffee.

The Krups Simply Brew Coffee Maker is a good choice for people who want a simple and compact coffee maker that can brew enough coffee for one or two people.

It has some basic features that make it convenient and easy to use, such as the top water tank, the pause and serve system, the keep warm function, and the removable filter basket.

It does not have any advanced features such as programmability, strength selection, or pause-and-serve function, so it may not suit people who want more control or variety in their coffee.

It also does not have a thermal carafe or a permanent filter, so it may not keep your coffee hot for long or reduce sediment in your cup.

However, for its price and size, it is a decent coffee maker that can deliver consistent and satisfying results.


Here are some other great options you can consider:


Also Great

BLACK+DECKER DCM600B

BLACK+DECKER 5-Cup Coffeemaker, Black, DCM600B

The BLACK+DECKER 5-Cup Coffeemaker, Model DCM600B, is an affordable option with a compact design that won’t take up much space in your kitchen.

Its nonstick carafe plate keeps your coffee warm for up to an hour after brewing.

Pros

Budget-friendly

Compact design

Keeps coffee warm for up to an hour

Cons

I found a strong plastic taste

This Black and Decker coffee maker is a compact and simple coffee maker that can brew up to five cups of coffee at a time.

It has a few features that make it convenient and reliable, such as the Duralife glass carafe, the nonstick keep-hot carafe plate, the removable filter basket, and the easy-view water window.

  • Duralife glass carafe: The coffee maker comes with a reinforced glass carafe that is built to last. It has coffee and water markings that help you measure the right amount of coffee and water for your desired number of cups. It also has a sturdy handle and a drip-free spout that make it easy to pour and serve. The carafe is dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning.
  • Nonstick keep-hot carafe plate: The coffee maker has a nonstick warming plate that keeps your coffee hot for up to an hour after brewing is complete. This ensures that every cup you drink is fresh and flavorful, even if you brew your coffee ahead of time. The nonstick coating also makes it easy to wipe off any spills or stains.
  • Removable filter basket: The coffee maker has a removable filter basket that makes for simple cleanup. You don’t have to use paper filters or worry about running out of them. You can simply wash the filter basket after each use and reuse it for the next brew. The filter basket is compatible with the BLACK+DECKER Water Filtration Disk & Frame (sold separately), which can help remove chlorine and other impurities from water and improve the taste of your coffee.
  • Easy-view water window: The coffee maker has a clear water window on the side that lets you see how much water you are adding to the reservoir. This can help you prevent overflows or underfills, which can affect the quality of your coffee. The water window has markings for 2, 3, 4, and 5 cups, so you can easily adjust the water level according to your preference.

This Black and Decker 5 cup coffee maker is a great option for people who want a simple and compact coffee maker that can brew enough coffee for one or two people.

It has some basic features that make it convenient and reliable, such as the Duralife glass carafe, the nonstick keep-hot carafe plate, the removable filter basket, and the easy-view water window.

It does not have any advanced features such as programmability, strength selection, or pause-and-serve function, so it may not suit people who want more control or variety in their coffee.

It also does not have a thermal carafe or a permanent filter, so it may not keep your coffee hot for long or reduce sediment in your cup.

However, for its price and size, this coffee maker is one of the best 5-cup coffee makers on the market today that can deliver consistent and satisfying results.


Also Great

Mr. Coffee Programmable Coffee Maker

Mr. Coffee Programmable Coffee Maker with Auto Pause and Glass Carafe

The Mr. Coffee programmable coffee maker features auto pause, allowing you to stop the brewing process briefly and pour a cup before it fully completes.

With a 5-cup capacity and a glass carafe, it’s a reliable option for daily use.

Pros

Programmable

Auto pause feature

Glass carafe

Cons

I found it difficult to see water levels during filling

This 5 cup programmable coffee maker is a compact and simple coffee maker that can brew up to 25 ounces of coffee, enough for two 12-ounce cups.

It has a few features that make it easy to use and clean, such as the programmable timer, the auto pause, the water filtration disk, and the reusable filter.

  • Programmable timer: The coffee maker has a programmable timer that lets you set your coffee maker ahead of time and wake up to fresh brewed coffee. This feature can help you save time and enjoy your morning routine without having to wait for your coffee to brew. You can easily set the timer using the buttons and the LCD display on the front of the coffee maker.
  • Auto pause: The coffee maker has an auto pause feature that lets you stop the brewing cycle to pour a cup of coffee, then continue brewing until complete. This feature can help you avoid wasting coffee or overfilling the carafe. You don’t have to wait for the entire pot to finish brewing before you can enjoy your first cup. You can also prevent spilling coffee on the counter or the warming plate. The auto pause feature works by automatically stopping the flow of coffee when you remove the carafe from the warming plate, and resuming it when you place it back.
  • Water filtration disk: The coffee maker comes with a water filtration disk and frame that can help remove chlorine and other impurities from water and improve the taste of your coffee. This feature can help you brew better quality coffee with less bitterness or off-flavors. You can easily insert the water filtration disk and frame into the filter basket and replace it every month or after 30 brew cycles. The red tab on the disk frame lets you know when it’s time to change the water filter.
  • Reusable filter: The coffee maker has a reusable filter basket that can save you money and reduce waste. You don’t have to buy disposable paper filters or worry about running out of them. You can simply wash the filter basket after each use and reuse it for the next brew. The filter basket is dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.

This 5-cup programmable coffee maker is a good option for people who want a simple and compact coffee maker that can brew enough coffee for two people.

It has some basic features that make it easy to use and clean, such as the programmable timer, the auto pause, the water filtration disk, and the reusable filter.

The auto pause feature allows you to stop the brewing process briefly and pour a cup before it fully completes.

With a 5-cup capacity and a glass carafe, it’s a reliable option for daily use. It’s also one of the most user-friendly 5 cup coffee machines you can find.

It does not have any advanced features such as strength selection, temperature control, or thermal carafe, so it may not suit people who want more customization or variety in their coffee.

It also does not have a keep-warm function or an auto-shutoff feature, so it may not keep your coffee hot for long or prevent overheating or fire hazards.

However, for its price and size, it is a decent coffee maker that can deliver consistent and satisfying results.


Also Great

Holstein Housewares – 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker

Holstein Housewares – 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker

The Holstein Housewares 5 Cup drip coffee machine offers convenience and user-friendliness with its permanent filter, borosilicate glass carafe, and water level indicator.

It also comes with auto pause/serve and keep warm functions to enhance your coffee experience.

Pros

Permanent filter

Auto pause/serve

Keep warm function

Cons

It did not feel very durable

This coffee maker has a simple one-touch operation that allows you to start and stop the brewing process with ease.

It also has a permanent filter and a measuring spoon included, so you don’t have to worry about buying paper filters or measuring the coffee grounds.

The glass carafe has a water level indicator that shows you how much water you need to fill for the desired number of cups. The carafe also has a handle and a spout that make it easy to pour and serve the coffee without spilling.

One of the features that sets this coffee maker apart from others is the auto pause and serve function. This means that you can pause the brewing cycle and pour yourself a cup of coffee before it is finished, without making a mess or compromising the taste.

This is great if you are in a hurry or just can’t wait for the whole pot to be ready. The coffee maker will resume the brewing process once you place the carafe back on the warming plate.

Another feature that we like about this coffee maker is the keep warm function.

This function keeps the coffee hot for up to two hours after the coffee brewing cycle is completed, so you can enjoy a second or third cup without having to reheat it.

The warming plate has a non-stick coating that prevents the coffee from burning or sticking to it.

The coffee maker also has an automatic shut-off feature that turns off the power after two hours, for safety and energy saving purposes.

The Holstein Housewares – 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker has a sleek and colorful design that adds a pop of personality to your kitchen.

It comes in four different colors: red, teal, mint, and black.

The coffee maker has a space-saving design that takes up less room on your countertop than other models.

It also has a stow-away power cord that can be tucked away when not in use, for a neat and tidy look.

The Holstein Housewares – 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker is easy to clean and maintain.

The removable filter basket and the carafe are dishwasher safe, so you can simply rinse them and put them in the dishwasher after each use.

The exterior of the coffee maker can be wiped with a damp cloth to remove any dust or stains.

The Holstein Housewares – 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker is a convenient and user-friendly coffee maker that makes great tasting coffee.

It can make up to five cups of freshly brewed and rich-tasting coffee at a time.

It has some features that make it stand out from other models, such as the auto pause and serve function, the keep warm function, and the colorful design.

It also comes with everything you need to start making coffee right away, such as a permanent filter, a measuring spoon, and a glass carafe.

It is easy to operate, clean, and store, making it a great addition to your kitchen.


Also Great

Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker

Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker

The Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker features a black and stainless steel design and offers a reusable gold-tone filter.

Its brew-through lid ensures heat retention, maintaining the temperature and quality of your coffee.

Pros

Reusable gold-tone filter

Stylish design

Brew-through lid

Cons

There may be leaking issues

The Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker is designed for small spaces and easy operation.

It has a glass carafe with a brew-through lid, a permanent filter that eliminates the need for paper filters, and a 24-hour programmable clock/timer with an LCD display.

It also has a drip stop feature that allows you to pour a cup while brewing, a non-stick warming plate that keeps the coffee hot for two hours, and a two-hour safety shut-off.

The water level indicator shows how much water you need to brew 1 to 5 cups of coffee.

This coffee maker is ideal for people who want a simple and convenient way to make delicious coffee without wasting paper filters or space.


Also Great

Cuisinart DCC-5570

Cuisinart DCC-5570 5-Cup Coffeemaker with Stainless Steel Carafe

The Cuisinart DCC-5570 has a brushed stainless steel carafe, enhancing its overall durability, and features a brew pause function.

It also includes a 24-hour programmable timer, allowing you to make coffee ahead of time.

Pros

Stainless steel carafe

Brew pause

24-hour programmable timer

Cons

Expensive compared to similar models

The Cuisinart DCC-5570 5-Cup Coffeemaker with Stainless Steel Carafe offers a stylish and functional solution for small kitchens.

It has a stainless steel carafe with a dripless pour spout and a knuckle guard, a removable water reservoir that makes it easy to fill and clean, and an easy on/off switch and brew pause feature.

It also has a 30-minute keep warm feature that keeps the coffee at the optimal temperature, a charcoal water filter and a permanent coffee filter that improve the taste and quality of the coffee, and a small, compact design that saves counter space.

This coffee maker is perfect for people who want a durable and elegant coffee maker that can brew up to 5 cups of flavorful coffee in minutes.


Also Great

BLACK+DECKER CM0700BZ

BLACK+DECKER 5-Cup Coffeemaker, Black, CM0700BZ

The BLACK+DECKER CM0700BZ Coffeemaker features a compact design and boasts a sleek black aesthetic.

It includes a removable filter basket, making cleaning easier, and features a water level indicator for accurate measurements.

Pros

Compact design

Removable filter basket

Water level indicator

Cons

The coffee can taste a bit weak

This Black and Decker coffee maker is simple and reliable, with a one-touch control and an illuminated on/off switch.

It has a glass carafe with an ergonomic handle and measurement markings, a non-stick carafe plate that keeps the coffee warm for two hours, and a removable filter basket that uses basket-style filters and is easy to clean.

It also has a front-fill water reservoir and a swing-out brew basket that are designed for easy access under cabinets, reducing spills and messes.

It also has a brew pause feature that lets you pour a cup before the brewing cycle is finished.

This coffee maker is great for people who want an affordable and easy-to-use coffee maker that can brew up to 5 cups of hot coffee at a time.


Also Great

Zojirushi EC-DAC50 Zutto

Zojirushi EC-DAC50 Zutto 5-Cup Drip Coffeemaker

Zojirushi’s EC-DAC50 Zutto is known for its high-quality performance and sleek silver design.

Though it’s more expensive than other models, the quality and reliability of this coffee maker are often praised by users.

Pros

High-quality performance

Sleek design

Cons

Expensive compared to similar models

Zojirushi EC-DAC50 Zutto 5-Cup Drip Coffeemaker is sleek and stylish, with a removable water tank and water filter that lasts up to 2 years under normal use.

It brews up to 5 cups of coffee into the improved Duralife glass carafe, which has a comfortable handle and drip-free pouring.

The filter cone is located inside the carafe, which makes it more compact and prevents dripping.

It also has an automatic keep warm function that keeps the coffee hot for up to an hour, and an easy-to-read LCD display that shows the time and settings.

This coffee maker is ideal for people who want a sophisticated and efficient coffee maker that can make smooth and rich coffee with minimal maintenance.


Also Great

Hamilton Beach (46111)

Hamilton Beach 5 Cup Compact Drip Coffee Maker (46111)

The Hamilton Beach 46111 coffee maker offers a programmable clock and auto pause/pour function, allowing convenience and control over your coffee brewing.

Its glass carafe and black & stainless steel finish provide a stylish touch to your kitchen.

Pros

Programmable clock

Auto pause and pour

Stylish design

Cons

I found difficult to fill the water reservoir

The Hamilton Beach 5 Cup Compact Drip Coffee Maker is smart and versatile, with a programmable clock that lets you set the brewing time up to 24 hours in advance.

It has a glass carafe with a brew-through lid and an ergonomic handle, a removable water reservoir that makes it easy to fill without using the carafe, and an auto pause and pour feature that lets you grab a cup mid-brew without making a mess.

It also has a lift and clean dishwasher-safe brew basket that uses cone-shaped filters, an easy-touch programming button, and an automatic shut-off feature after two hours of keeping the coffee warm.

This coffee maker is perfect for people who want a compact and customizable coffee maker that can brew up to 5 cups of fresh and hot coffee whenever they want.


Also Great

Mixpresso 5-Cup Drip Coffee Maker

Mixpresso 5-Cup Drip Coffee Maker

The Mixpresso 5-Cup Drip Coffee Maker is a compact and efficient coffee machine, perfect for those with limited space.

Its reusable and removable coffee filter adds convenience, and its 650-watt motor ensures quick brewing.

Pros

Compact design

Reusable filter

Quick brewing

Cons

I found the taste quality inconsistent

The Mixpresso 5-Cup Drip Coffee Maker is a budget-friendly option for small spaces and easy operation.

It has a glass carafe with a brew-through lid, a permanent filter that eliminates the need for paper filters, and an illuminated one-touch button on/off switch.

It also has a transparent water window that allows you to see how much water you need to brew 1 to 5 cups of coffee, a non-stick warming plate that keeps the coffee hot for two hours, and a two-hour safety shut-off feature.

This coffee maker is suitable for people who want a simple and convenient way to make delicious coffee without wasting paper filters or space.


Also Great

Keurig K-2500TM

Keurig K-2500TM 5 Cups Coffee Maker

The Keurig K2500 coffee maker offers versatility with its 5-cup capacity and ability to brew single-serve cups as well.

It also includes a strong brew setting for those preferring a more robust flavor.

Pros

Versatile

Strong brew setting

Sleek design

Cons

Relatively expensive

The Keurig K2500 K-2500TM 5 Cups Coffee Maker is a versatile and smart solution for medium- to large-size businesses.

It can brew up to 5 cups of coffee in different sizes (4, 6, 8, 10, and 12 oz.), and has a strong button that increases the strength and bold taste of your coffee.

It can connect directly to a water line or use a water reservoir (sold separately), and has a manual for safety and peace of mind.

It also has an easy-to-read LCD display that shows the time and settings, and a USB port that allows you to upload photos to the screensaver.

Similar to other Keurigs, this coffee maker is ideal for people who want a durable and customizable coffee maker that can brew smooth and rich coffee with minimal maintenance.


Also Great

Bonavita 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker e

Bonavita 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker Machine, One-Touch Pour Over Brewing w/Double Wall Thermal Carafe, SCA Certified, 1100 Watt

The Bonavita 5-Cup Drip Coffee Maker is SCA certified, ensuring a high-quality brew.

Its one-touch pour-over brewing and a double-wall thermal carafe add convenience and functionality to your daily coffee routine.

Pros

SCA certified

One-touch brewing

Double-wall thermal carafe

Cons

Higher price point compared to other 5-cup coffee makers

The Bonavita 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker is a high-quality and elegant option for small kitchens.

It is certified by the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) as a Golden Cup Standard Coffee Machine, which means it meets the rigorous standards for optimal flavor extraction and brewing consistency.

It has a stainless steel thermal carafe with a dripless pour spout and a knuckle guard, a removable water reservoir that makes it easy to fill and clean, and an one-touch operation with an automatic shut-off feature.

It also has a showerhead and filter basket that work in harmony to evenly saturate coffee grounds for uniform flavor extraction, and an optional pre-infusion mode that allows fresh roasted coffee to bloom before brewing to enhance its flavor.

This coffee maker is perfect for people who want a sophisticated and efficient coffee maker that can make smooth and rich coffee with minimal fuss.


Also Great

Gevi 5 Cup Coffee Maker

Gevi 5 Cup Coffee Maker

The Gevi 5 Cup Coffee Maker is a compact and efficient coffee machine that can brew up to 25 ounces of coffee in one cycle. 

It features a reusable filter that saves you money and reduces waste, and a 650-watt motor that ensures fast brewing. 

It also has a sleek black design that adds a touch of elegance to your kitchen

Pros

One-touch control for easy operation

Removable filter basket for convenient cleaning

30 seconds of auto-pause for pouring a cup mid-brew

Keeping warm feature to maintain coffee temperature

Cons

The coffee is sometimes not hot enough

The water level indicator may be inaccurate sometimes

Some users report the carafe is prone to leaking

This coffee maker is a simple and reliable option for everyday use.

It has a glass carafe with an ergonomic handle and measurement markings, a removable filter basket that uses basket-style filters and is easy to clean, and an easy on/off switch and brew pause feature.

It also has a front-fill water reservoir and a swing-out brew basket that are designed for easy access under cabinets, reducing spills and messes.

It also has an automatic shut-off feature after two hours of keeping the coffee warm. This coffee maker is great for people who want an affordable and easy-to-use coffee maker that can brew up to 5 cups of hot coffee at a time.


Why Choose a 5-Cup Coffee Maker?

There are various reasons why someone might want to buy a 5-cup coffee maker.

One main reason could be to brew the full amount of coffee you want to drink in one batch. This allows you to avoid wasting coffee, reheating stale coffee, and enjoy fresh and hot coffee every time. Moreover, it saves you time and energy.

Another reason might be to share coffee with your partner or a friend.

A 5-cup coffee maker provides enough coffee for two mugs each, making it perfect for couples who want to bond over a cup of joe.

It provides more than what a 4-cup coffee brewer can give you, so you can have an extra cup of coffee for yourself, someone else, or even save some for later.

This also helps satisfy your caffeine cravings, fueling your productivity, and leaving some leftovers for other purposes like baking or cooking.

Choosing a 5 cup coffee maker is also an eco-friendly decision. You can reduce your environmental impact and save money by brewing only what you need and avoiding throwing away unused coffee grounds or filters.

Plus, this approach uses less water and electricity, which is not only good for the environment but also for your wallet.

Last but not least, if you have limited space, a 5-cup coffee machine could be an ideal choice.

These compact and lightweight coffee makers can easily fit in your kitchen, office, dorm, or RV, helping you save counter space and storage space while still enjoying the convenience and simplicity of a small appliance.

Remember to enjoy your coffee responsibly and choose the right size coffee maker that suits your needs and lifestyle!

How to Choose: Your Guide to The Best 5 Cup Coffee Makers

When selecting the perfect 5-cup coffee maker for your needs, consider the following factors to ensure you’re getting the most out of your purchase:

Coffee quality

Select a coffee maker that delivers consistent flavor and aroma. The brewing temperature should be between 195°F and 205°F for optimal extraction.

Filters

Consider the type of filters the coffee maker uses: reusable or disposable. Reusable filters are more cost-effective and environmentally friendly, while disposable ones may provide better filtering.

Size and Weight

Analyze the space available in your kitchen to ensure the coffee maker fits comfortably. Smaller and lightweight models are ideal for limited spaces.

Programmable Features

Opt for a coffee maker with programmable settings like auto-start and auto-shutoff for added convenience.

Brewing Method

Choose a coffee brewing method that suits your taste preferences, such as drip, pour-over, or percolator.

Cup Size

Ensure the coffee maker brews the appropriate amount of coffee, according to your desired servings. Adjustability in cup size may be a valuable feature.

Design

Look for a sleek design that complements your kitchen’s aesthetics.

Ease of Use and Cleaning

Select a coffee maker with intuitive controls and removable parts for easy cleaning.

Price and Warranty

Find a coffee maker that fits your budget, and make sure it comes with a good warranty for coverage against any potential defects.

Durability

Choose a coffee maker made of high-quality materials to ensure durability and longevity.

Carafe Material

Decide between a glass or thermal carafe, based on your preference for heat retention and durability.

Water Reservoir

A coffee maker with an easily accessible and removable water reservoir makes filling and cleaning a breeze.

Brand Reputation

Choose a coffee maker from a reputable brand known for producing reliable and high-quality machines.

Extra Features

Look out for additional features such as an integrated grinder, milk frother, or thermal carafe that could enhance your coffee experience.

How to Clean Your 5-Cup Coffee Maker

Keeping your 5-cup coffee maker clean is essential for making great-tasting freshly brewed coffee.

Let’s go through a quick and easy process to clean it regularly. You’ll be back to enjoying your daily cup of Joe in no time.

Step 1: Gather your supplies. You’ll need the following items:

  • Distilled white vinegar
  • Water
  • Coffee filters
  • A clean rag or microfiber cloth

Step 2: Mix the cleaning solution. Fill the carafe with equal parts of water and distilled white vinegar. This solution will help remove mineral buildup and lingering coffee oils.

Step 3: Prep your coffee maker. Remove any used coffee grounds and filter. Replace the filter with a fresh one and place the carafe back on the coffee maker.

Step 4: Run the cleaning cycle. Pour the water-vinegar mix into the coffee maker’s water reservoir. Start the brewing process and let it run its full cycle. The solution will break down the buildup and clean your coffee maker’s internals. Don’t worry; your coffee won’t taste like vinegar later.

Step 5: Wait and rinse. Once the cycle is done, let the coffee maker sit idle for 15-30 minutes to allow the vinegar solution to work its magic. Afterward, remove and discard the filter, rinse the carafe, and wipe down the exterior of the machine with a clean cloth.

Step 6: Run two water-only cycles. Fill the carafe with fresh water and run two full brewing cycles without coffee grounds or a filter. This will flush and rinse out the remaining vinegar and ensure your coffee maker is ready to brew excellent coffee again.

That’s all you need to do to clean your 5-cup coffee maker! Just remember to maintain this routine every month if you’re an avid coffee drinker or every three to six months if you brew coffee occasionally. Cheers to your clean and happy coffee maker!

Comparing the 15 Best 5-Cup Coffee Makers

ModelKey FeaturesProsCons
Mr. Coffee 2129512, 5-Cup Mini Brew Switch Coffee Maker, BlackOn/off indicator light, removable filter basket, grab-a-cup auto pause, water window, lift and clean filter basketEasy to use, removable filter basketLimited features
Amazon Basics 5 Cup Coffee Maker with Reusable Filter, Black and Stainless SteelReusable filter, water window, keep-warm function, auto-shutoff featureReusable filter, pause-and-serve functionSome users report difficulty in pouring without spills
Krups Simply Brew Stainless Steel Drip Coffee Maker 5 Cup 650 Watts Coffee Filter, Drip Free, Dishwasher Safe Pot, Compact Silver and BlackTop water tank, pause and serve system, keep warm function, removable filter basketCompact design, dishwasher-safe pot, drip-free spoutSome users report inconsistent taste quality
BLACK+DECKER 5-Cup Coffeemaker, Black, DCM600BDuralife glass carafe, nonstick keep-hot carafe plate, removable filter basket, easy-view water windowBudget-friendly, compact design, keeps coffee warm for up to an hourSome users report a strong plastic taste
Mr. Coffee Coffee Maker, Programmable Coffee Machine with Auto Pause and Glass Carafe, 5 Cups, BlackProgrammable timer, auto pause, water filtration disk, reusable filterProgrammable, auto pause feature, glass carafeSome find it difficult to see water levels during filling
Holstein Housewares – 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker – Convenient and User Friendly with Permanent Filter, Borosilicate Glass Carafe, Water Level Indicator, Auto Pause/Serve and Keep Warm Functions, TealPermanent filter, water level indicator, auto pause/serve and keep warm functionsPermanent filter, auto pause/serve function, keep warm functionDurability issues reported by some users
Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker, Black and Stainless SteelReusable gold-tone filter, stylish design, brew-through lidReusable gold-tone filter, stylish design, brew-through lidSome users report leaking issues
Cuisinart DCC-5570 5-Cup Coffeemaker with Stainless Steel CarafeStainless steel carafe with dripless pour spout and knuckle guard; removable water reservoir; easy on/off switch and brew pause feature; charcoal water filter and permanent-style nylon coffee filter; small compact design.Stainless steel carafe; brew pause; charcoal water filter.Expensive compared to similar models.
BLACK+DECKER 5-Cup Coffeemaker; Black; CM0700BZGlass carafe with ergonomic handle and measurement markings; removable filter basket that uses basket-style filters; easy on/off switch and brew pause feature; front-fill water reservoir and swing-out brew basket; automatic shut-off feature after two hours of keeping the coffee warm.Compact design; removable filter basket; water level indicator.Some users report the coffee’s taste can be weak.
Zojirushi EC-DAC50 Zutto 5-Cup Drip Coffeemaker; SilverRemovable water tank and water filter that lasts up to 2 years under normal use; glass carafe with a brew-through lid; filter cone located inside the carafe for compactness and drip prevention; automatic keep warm function; easy-to-read LCD display; USB port for uploading photos to the screensaver.High-quality performance; sleek design.Expensive compared to other 5-cup coffee makers.
Hamilton Beach 5 Cup Compact Drip Coffee Maker with Programmable Clock; Glass Carafe; Auto Pause and Pour; Black & Stainless Steel (46111)Programmable clock that lets you set the brewing time up to 24 hours in advance; glass carafe with a brew-through lid and an ergonomic handle; removable water reservoir that makes it easy to fill without using the carafe; auto pause and pour feature that lets you grab a cup mid-brew without making a mess; lift and clean dishwasher-safe brew basket that uses cone-shaped filters.Programmable clock; auto pause and pour; stylish design.Some users reported difficulty in filling the water reservoir.
Mixpresso 5-Cup Drip Coffee Maker; Electric Coffee Pot Machine Including Reusable And Removable Coffee Filter; Small; 25 oz; 650W.Glass carafe with an ergonomic handle and measurement markings; permanent filter that eliminates the need for paper filters; illuminated one-touch button on/off switch; transparent water window that shows how much water you need to brew 1 to 5 cups of coffee; non-stick warming plate that keeps the coffee hot for two hours; two-hour safety shut-off feature.Compact design; reusable filter; quick brewing.Some users found the taste to be inconsistent.
Keurig K2500 K-2500TM 5 Cups Coffee Maker; 12 ounces; Black/SilverCan brew up to 5 cups of coffee in different sizes (4, 6, 8, 10, and 12 oz.); strong button that increases the strength and bold taste of your coffee; can connect directly to a water line or use a water reservoir (sold separately); manual for safety and peace of mind; easy-to-read LCD display that shows the time and settings; USB port that allows you to upload photos to the screensaver.Versatile; strong brew setting; sleek design.Relatively expensive.
Bonavita 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker Machine; One-Touch Pour Over Brewing w/Double Wall Thermal Carafe; SCA Certified; 1100 WattCertified by the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) as a Golden Cup Standard Coffee Machine; stainless steel thermal carafe with a dripless pour spout and a knuckle guard; removable water reservoir that makes it easy to fill and clean; one-touch operation with an automatic shut-off feature; showerhead and filter basket that work in harmony to evenly saturate coffee grounds for uniform flavor extraction; optional pre-infusion mode that allows allows the coffee to bloom before brewing to enhance its flavor.SCA certified; one-touch brewing; double-wall thermal carafe.Higher price point compared to other 5-cup coffee makers.
Gevi 5 Cup Coffee MakerGlass carafe with an ergonomic handle and measurement markings; removable filter basket that uses basket-style filters and is easy to clean; easy on/off switch and brew pause feature; front-fill water reservoir and swing-out brew basket that are designed for easy access under cabinets, reducing spills and messes; automatic shut-off feature after two hours of keeping the coffee warm.Compact design; removable filter basket; water level indicator.Some users report the coffee is not hot enough.
Table comparing the 15 Best 5-Cup Coffee Makers

Conclusion

So, you’ve reached the end of this article, and you’re probably wondering which 5-cup coffee maker can best satisfy your caffeine cravings without wasting coffee or space, right? There are quite a few great options out there, but let’s recap some of our favorites.

Our top pick is the Mr. Coffee 2129512, 5-Cup Mini Brew Switch Coffee Maker, Black. This coffee maker is simple yet functional, offering an on/off indicator light and a removable filter basket for easy cleaning. It’s ideal for those who want a straightforward and reliable machine that can brew the perfect amount of coffee for smaller households.

If you’re on a tight budget, you might want to consider the Amazon Basics 5 Cup Coffee Maker with Reusable Filter, Black and Stainless Steel. This coffee maker comes with a reusable filter that saves you money and reduces waste. It also has a pause-and-serve function that lets you enjoy a cup of coffee before the brewing cycle is complete.

If you’re looking for a compact 5 cup and stylish coffee maker that can brew quickly and cleanly, you might like the Krups Simply Brew Stainless Steel Drip Coffee Maker 5 Cup 650 Watts Coffee Filter, Drip Free, Dishwasher Safe Pot, Compact Silver and Black. This coffee maker has a dishwasher-safe pot for easy cleaning and a drip-free spout that prevents spills, so you can sneak a cup of coffee without leaving a trail. It also has a 650-watt motor that ensures fast brewing.

You may also opt for an espresso machine instead. However, no matter which 5-cup coffee maker you choose, make sure to clean and maintain it regularly to ensure its longevity and optimal performance. With a 5-cup coffee maker, you can enjoy the benefits of a small appliance that delivers fresh and delicious coffee every time. Cheers!


Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top features to consider for a 5-cup coffee maker?

When looking for a 5-cup coffee maker, consider features such as programmability, brew speed, ease of use, and whether it includes a reusable coffee filter. Additionally, consider the coffee maker’s size and design to ensure it fits well in your kitchen.

Which coffee makers are best for small kitchens?

For small kitchens, consider compact 5-cup coffee makers designed with a small footprint. The best options include Mr. Coffee 5 Cup Programmable 25 Oz and Gevi 5 cup coffee maker. These models are easy to set up, clean, and boast a simple one-touch operation.

How do different 5-cup coffee maker models compare?

5-cup coffee maker models vary in design, features, and performance. Compare factors like brewing time, programmable settings, ease of cleaning, and overall build quality. You can also compare based on factors like energy efficiency and the type of carafe provided.

Are there budget-friendly high-quality 5-cup coffee makers?

Yes, there are budget-friendly high-quality 5-cup coffee makers available. Research and compare products to ensure you find a coffee maker that meets your needs and falls within your budget. Reading customer reviews and expert recommendations can help you make an informed decision.

How energy efficient are various 5-cup coffee makers?

Energy efficiency varies among 5-cup coffee makers. Some models include features such as automatic shut-off, energy-saving modes, and insulated carafes to help conserve power. Check the product’s manual or specifications for information on energy usage.

What are some reliable 5-cup coffee maker brands?

Some reliable 5-cup coffee maker brands include Mr. Coffee, Gevi, and Black+Decker. Consider reading customer reviews to find the best machine to suit your needs.

How much coffee do I put in a 5 cup coffee brewer?

See how much coffee you need depends from machine to machine. The general rule of thumb is one tablespoon of coffee per six ounces of water. As 5-cup coffee makers usually have a capacity of around 25 ounces, you would need about four tablespoons of coffee. If you like coffee beans instead, consider buying a bean-to-cup machine. 

What is the ratio of coffee to water?

A standard ratio for coffee to water is 1:16 – one part coffee to 16 parts water. You can adjust this ratio depending on your taste preference.

How often should you clean your coffee maker?

It’s recommended to clean your coffee maker at least once a month, or after 20-30 brewing cycles. Regular cleaning prolongs the life of your coffee maker and ensures optimal performance.

How many mugs will I get out of a 5 cup coffee maker?

Typically, a 5-cup coffee maker will yield around 4 to 5 standard 6-ounce mugs of coffee. The actual number depends on the size of your mugs and your preferred coffee strength. If you like coffee beans instead, consider buying a bean-to-cup machine.

Which is better? A glass carafe or a thermal carafe?

Both glass and thermal carafes have their advantages. Glass carafes are generally less expensive and allow you to see the coffee level easily. On the other hand, thermal carafes are better at keeping coffee warm for extended periods. Choose the one from our list of the best that suits your needs and personal preferences.

What is the best 5 cup coffee maker 2023?

Our top pick for 2023 is the Mr. Coffee 2129512, 5-Cup Mini Brew Switch Coffee Maker, Black

Photo of author

AUTHOR

Coffee aficionado Ryan Bahar is the Editor-in-Chief at CoffeeGrabber.com. While most people love a good morning cup of joe, only a few can appreciate the art involved in grinding coffee beans, taste the difference between coffee from Ethiopia to Guatemala to Colombia, or identify terrible coffee products dressed up with fancy marketing. Ryan wants to use his coffee expertise to bring you the most authentic coffee tips, guides and reviews on the web.